Antonyms for the phrase "fingered the pie" could include: untouched, unspoiled, unaffected, unstirred, unaltered, unharmed, untampered with, unexplored, and unscathed. These words indicate a lack of interference or manipulation with the pie in question. If someone did not "finger the pie," it means they did not probe or meddle with it. Additionally, the antonyms suggest that the pie is in its original state, unchanged by any outside factors. By choosing to use antonyms of "fingered the pie," one can evoke a sense of purity or naturalness in regards to the pie's appearance and quality.