When looking for synonyms for the phrase "shame tingled his cheeks," words that come to mind include embarrassment, humiliation, mortification, and chagrin. These terms all express a sense of shame or disgrace that one might feel in a given situation. Other synonyms may include blushing, flushing, feeling red-faced, or experiencing a heat of the moment. No matter the terminology used, the overall sentiment remains the same: the individual in question is feeling a deep sense of embarrassment or guilt that is manifesting physically on their face. Choosing the right synonym requires considering the context and intensity of the situation in question.