Unshepherdly is an uncommon word, often used to describe someone who lacks the qualities of a wise and caring shepherd. Though limited in its variations, there are a few synonymous terms that can be adopted to convey the same essence. Words like 'unguided' emphasize the absence of guidance or leadership. 'Unruly' encapsulates a sense of disorder or disobedience, highlighting a lack of discipline. 'Neglected' alludes to the negligence of duty or responsibility, reflecting a failure to care for others. While 'untamed' suggests a wild or uncontrolled nature, it can also imply a disregard for the needs of those being tended.