When analyzing or reviewing something, it's important to approach it with a critical eye. However, using the same phrase repetitively in writing can become tedious for the reader. There are several synonyms for "with a critical eye" that can be used to make your writing more engaging and diverse. Some of these synonyms include scrutinizingly, judiciously, analytically, objectively, and discerningly. By choosing different words to convey the same meaning, you can add variation and depth to your writing, making it more effective at engaging your audience. Therefore, next time you want to describe how you're carefully considering something, don't forget to try using different synonyms for "with a critical eye".