The term "bookworm trophy" can be substituted with various synonyms depending on the context and purpose. A few examples include "literary prize," "reading award," and "book lover recognition." "Intellectual accolade," "brainy award," and "scholarly honor" are also fitting alternatives. For a more humorous take, one can use "page-turner prize," "novel nerd award," or "bookish badge." "Bibliophile commendation," "prose accolade," and "word warrior trophy" also convey the essence of a bookworm trophy. It is important to match the synonym with the intended message and audience to ensure maximum impact and resonance.