Their judgment was for the defendants.
"Memoirs of Orange Jacobs"
Orange Jacobs
The defendants had vigorously denied that the power of Congress over interstate commerce was extended to the regulation of railway corporations organized under State laws, by reason of these corporations engaging in interstate commerce.
"History of the United States, Volume 6 (of 6)"
E. Benjamin Andrews
The counsel for the defence argued that no case could be set up under the Sherman act, since the defendants were not engaged in interstate commerce, implying that a combination of laborers was not a violation of the act.
"History of the United States, Volume 6 (of 6)"
E. Benjamin Andrews