"Button lip" implies a person who is quiet and tight-lipped about their thoughts or feelings. Some antonyms for this phrase might include "voluble," "loquacious," or "garrulous," which all imply a great degree of verbal expressiveness. Other antonyms might include "unreserved," "outspoken," or "candid," all of which suggest a willingness to speak one's mind freely and with little inhibition. Ultimately, it depends on the context and intention of the communication whether an antonym for "button lip" is desirable or not. Some situations may call for more openness and frankness, while others may require more discretion and tact.